Attitudes.

By: Barnes, Clive
Publication: Dance Magazine
Date: Tuesday, February 1 2005

AMONG the major factors contributing to the health of the dance world-at least the American dance world, although surely, if only by ripple effect, internationally--is The New York Times. Of course, The New York Times is a huge fish in the ever-diminishing pool of print journalism, and still has

a significant influence on world affairs--not enough to elect a president, but sufficient to slightly color and flavor world opinion. Most people, institutions, and things would prefer to have The New York Times on their side rather than off it. But in dance matters The Times' influence has become enormous.

History--especially the virtual invention and early sustenance of modern dance--has placed the United States at the center of the dance world. And geography, economics, and cultural climate in turn placed New York at the center of the American dance world, the center's epicenter as it were. And in the New York performing arts, particularly in classical music, opera, and dance, The New York Times reigns supreme. As simple evidence of this, the vast proportion of dance companies and theaters' advertising budgets goes to The New York Times. The influence of its dance reviews, inside and outside the city, is enormous, and the particular tone it takes with dance and dance matters is crucial nowadays.

Luckily, over the years, The New York Times has done pretty well by dance. The dance community has been known to complain of its treatment, but generally speaking that treatment has been generous. It certainly used to live up to one of its advertising slogans suggesting to its readers "Find your world in our world." The paper has printed vastly more words and published more pictures about dance in the past 77 years than any other journalistic source. And why 77 years? Because that was when The New York Times appointed John Martin its first full-time chief (and only) dance critic.

SINCE Martin's retirement, there have been only four chief dance critics: Allen Hughes, from Martin's retirement in 1962 until 1965; me, originally an import from London, from 1965 until 1977; and Anna Kisselgoff from 1977 until last month, when she voluntarily and, in my view prematurely, stepped down (see "Transitions," page 145). She was replaced by John Rockwell, a polymath critic and erstwhile impresario presiding over the first years of the Lincoln Center Festival. His prime area of critical experience, like Hughes before him, had hitherto been music.

It is hardly an unbiased view, yet I feel the four dance critics who were Rockwell's predecessors did a good job. Martin laid the framework of American dance criticism today, championing modern dance from the get-go and later changing gears to embrace America's classical ballet with equal fervor. Hughes extended the range and scope of the dance coverage, a move I continued, making the dance pages more accessible perhaps because, in the other role of chief drama critic for 10 of my 12 Times years, I expanded the dance column's constituency. I also further extended the coverage by encouraging other writers: Don McDonagh, Kisselgoff, and Jennifer Dunning. As for Kisselgoff, she has left as a legacy of her 36 Times years (first as nay deputy, then for 27 years as the head of the department) one of the few major critical archives of 20th century dance.

And so on to the multi-talented Rockwell, who has both nay warmest wishes and highest hopes. However, it must be admitted that he ascends the throne of his minor duchy at a moment that seems altogether ominous for dance coverage in The New York Times. He must keep the faith in a climate where the once great Sunday Arts and Leisure section (which he at one time edited) has been culturally down-marketed to a kind of gee-whiz triviality--notably on its dance half-page. He must navigate a daily paper that, while devoting acres of space and gallons of words to the arts, has also begun to favor softly styled features over hard-headed reviews and to specialize in woozy news stories written by reporters hardly in command of their subject or in touch with their sources. Serious, informed comment on the dance scene has virtually disappeared from the pages of the paper, in what is fast becoming a broken record in arts coverage.

Rockwell, a fine writer and an editor of great discernment, even if one perhaps over-oriented to foreseeing the future rather than curating the past, is very conceivably just the right Timesman--one with sufficient in-paper authority and generalized background-at the right time for dance. I wish him well, for much of America's dance destiny rests, at least momentarily, on his shoulders. He will be more maligned than loved; I know this from experience as well as observation. And he is being given a slightly poisoned (something like "slightly pregnant?") chalice, from which he must drink deeply but wisely. The trick, by the way, is to filter with the teeth and avoid the lumps. God bless him and help him!

Senior Consulting Editor Clive Barnes also covers dance and theater for the New York Post.

Related Articles

  • A Shrivel of Dance Critics.
  • WHAT WOULD YOU CALL A ROOM CROWDED WITH DANCE CRITICS? WE HAVE WORDS THAT ARE CALLED COLLECTIVE NOUNS--SUCH AS AN EXALTATION OF LARKS, A PARLIAMENT OF OWLS, A CLOWDER OF CATS, AND A TIDING OF MAGPIES. It has been suggested ......
  • OBITUARIES.
  • Gary Parks (1955-99). It is with great sadness that we announce the passing of Gary Parks, 44, best known as the associate editor in charge of reviews and a member of the Dance Magazine staff since July 1985. Gary died ......
  • Play On!
  • IF MUSIC BE the food of dance, play on! Well, neither Shakespeare's Count Orsino nor New York City Ballet's George Balanchine actually said that, but I imagine both of them might have done. Perhaps we treat music a tad too ......
  • Olden days, golden days. (75).
  • OLDEN DAYS, GOLDEN DAYS" SANG FAY Templeton in Jerome Kern's Roberta. The song was "Yesterdays," and here are a few: * The first freelance article I wrote for Dance Magazine, in 1945, was assigned by an editor in her 50s ......
  • Fine line.
  • [ILLUSTRATION OMITTED] Elizabeth Parkinson and Scott Wise have both reached some of the highest highs any dancers can hope for on Broadway. After all, the pair met as cast members of the Broadway production of Fosse, a show made for ......
  • Questioning the quest for gold: after twenty-four years, Rhee Gold gets out of the competition business.
  • "American Dance Awards started small," remembers Rhee Gold about one of the first major dance competitions that grew into a giant in the field. And now, in spite of its success, he has just sold the family business. In 1973, ......
  • Focused on dance.
  • KELLY LYNN BURKE has studied dance for the past ten years; for nine of those years she has been attending competitions. At first she entered for fun and to gain experience performing. She still competes for those reasons, but these ......
  • Dance World '94 markets dance.
  • LONDON - Tattoos and tutus, boas and belly dancers, cobblers and choreographers - "Dance World |94' had them all. Visitors to Britain's first international trade fair for dance, held at the Barbican Exhibition Hall in central London, February 4-8, explored ......
  • The Last Impresario: The Life, Times, and Legacy of Sol Hurok.
  • Any reasonably thorough biography of the Ukranian-born American impresario Sol Hurok (1888-1974) would have to provide at least a capsule history of the American dance scene in the twentieth century. Though he made a fortune managing world-famous musicians, Hurok made ......
  • Attitudes.
  • Odd question. Would August Bournonville, that extraordinary Danish choreographer and exemplar of the essence of 19th-century Romantic ballet, have expected the international dance world to have celebrated the 200th anniversary of his birth with quite the vigor, devotion, and pleasure ......
  • A Lion's Share of Dance.
  • THE DANCE WORLD is a jungle where only the fittest survive for very long. Among the superior beings to have emerged from this Darwinian struggle is Garth Fagan, a Jamaican-born choreographer who weaves the supple syncopation of Africa and the ......
  • Reviews of the Century.
  • These excerpts from historic Dance Magazine reviews retain their original spelling and punctuation. Photos are from Dance Magazine Archives unless otherwise noted. In 1989 Richard Philp became Editor-in-Chief and Gary Parks, Reviews Editor 1988 NOVEMBER 15-20, 1988 EYE ON PERFORMANCE ......
  • Nebraska Helps Put Weidman Back On the Map.
  • Here in Charles Weidman's hometown, don't expect to see a plaque marking the spot where the modem-dance pioneer was born 100 years ago. In fact, don't even expect local dance experts to agree where the spot is. Expansion of the ......
  • Judson Revisited.
  • I HATE TO BE A CRUSTY OLD CURMUDGEON--BUT IF YOU ARE A CRUSTY OLD CURMUDGEON, WHAT CAN YOU REASONABLY BE EXPECTED TO DO ABOUT IT? AND EVEN CRUSTY OLD CURMUDGEONS HAVE RIGHTS AND OPINIONS. ESPECIALLY OPINIONS. This year on their ......
  • Transitions.
  • STEPHANIE REINHART Stephanie Reinhart, co-director of the American Dance Festival in Durham, North Carolina, and co-artistic director for dance at the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts in Washington, D.C. (see page 26), died September 23, 2002. According ......

Related Topics