Bearing witness to a crime.

By: Carey, Sean
Publication: New Internationalist
Date: Thursday, May 1 2008

'You had better examine your consciences,' Jon Castte told officials at the hastily convened British magistrates' court. He and fellow crew member Pete Bouquet, part of the 'People's Navy', had been put on trial for entering the three-mile (five-kilometre) exclusion zone around Diego Garcia which

forms part of the British Indian Ocean Territory and is home to a key US air and naval base.

The two British nationals, both lifelong environmental and human rights campaigners, had sailed 2,000 miles from Thailand aboard the recently renovated 12-metre sloop Musichana to highlight the plight of the 2,000 or so people who were forcibly removed from the Chagos Archipelago between 1968 and 1971 to make way for the military base. Bouquet and Castle said that they were motivated by the Quaker ideal that 'you should bear witness to a crime, even if you cannot stop it happening'.

Castle, Musichana's skipper, was given a six-month suspended prison sentence and fined [pounds sterling]3,000 ($6,000). However, his refusal to pay meant that the Musichana was confiscated and the two men deported to Singapore.

Since 2000, the Chagos Islanders, who live in exile in Mauritius and the Seychelles, have twice won the right of return to their homeland--once in the British High Court and again, last year, in the Court of Appeal. Despite these victories the British Government still refuses to allow them to go home, and so has decided to appeal to the House of Lords. The case will begin on 30 June.

Related Articles

  • BEARING WITNESS.
  • When the vagaries of American life and culture seem too much to bear, a dramatic change in perspective is in order. Break Point, a new book by Slovak Catholic layman Silvester Krcmery may be just the thing (Crossroad, 315 pp., ......
  • Police, prosecution court reforms vs crime pushed.
  • Carrying out genuine reforms in the countrys police, prosecution, and court system is the best way to combat criminality, not the lifting of the moratorium on the imposition of capital punishment. Thus pointed out Manila Mayor Lito Atienza as he ......
  • For the sake of Sue.
  • Even by a dinosaur's standards the Tyrannosaurus rex named Sue must have led an unusually difficult life. Its huge skeleton has scars aplenty, bearing witness to several life-threatening injuries sustained more than 65 million years ago. One leg shows a ......
  • Bearing Witness: Memories of Arkansas Slavery: Narratives from the 1930s WPA Collections.
  • Bearing Witness: Memories of Arkansas Slavery: Narratives from the 1930s WPA Collections. Edited by George E. Lankford. (Fayetteville: University of Arkansas Press, 2003. Pp. xxvii, 428. $34.95, ISBN 1-55728-747-3.) A curious distinction of George P. Rawick's monumental collection of WPA ......
  • Living by the word: bearing witness.
  • Sunday, August 26 Jeremiah 1:4-10; Psalm 71:1-6; Hebrews 12:18-29; Luke 13:10-17 FOR ALL OF HIS tears and lament, Jeremiah as portrayed in Jeremiah 1 is a bold young man mouthing off to God. Maybe the disrespect we sense in this ......
  • Reducing juvenile crime: conferencing versus court.
  • G. Luke & B. Lind Crime and Justice Bulletin, n.69, April, 2002, pp.1-20. The growth in interest in restorative justice has generated research in various areas including the effect of restorative justice sanctions on reoffending. This study compared reoffending by ......
  • Retirees: the "new kids" on campus. (Education).
  • SOME WALK INTO THE CLASS socializing about a party they attended last night; others are ready to get right down to business; and yet another group is huddled by the lecturer, eager to express opinions about the class topic. While ......
  • Bearing Witness: Readers, Writers, and the Novel in Nigeria.
  • Wendy Griswold. Bearing Witness: Readers, Writers, and the Novel in Nigeria. Princeton, N.J. Princeton University Press. 2000. xxiv + 340 pages, ill. $59.50 ($24.95 paper). ISBN 0-692-05828-8 (05829-6 paper). A LAGOS "GO SLOW" is the single most common scene in ......
  • A story of valor, betrayal.
  • Byline: Fr. Bel R. San Luis, SVD SOMETIME in March 2002 off Cartegena while Andy Moratillo, 31, and a fellow crew member were gazing at the vast ocean from the bridge of their ship M/T Ynca, they were startled to ......
  • Bilkis case: Crime was not pre-meditated, says court.
  • Byline: Kartikeya MUMBAI: Judge UD Salvi of the Mumbai special court hearing the Bilkis Bano case, also observed what the CBI had pointed out that the gruesome gangrape-massacre had occurred during riots and in a state where communal tension had ......
  • Bearing Witness.
  • Barbie Zelizer, Remembering to Forget: Holocaust Memory through the Camera's Eye. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1998. viii+292pp. $27.50 (cloth). Zelizer's work on how the photographic record of Nazi atrocities has been lodged into collective memory -- and as such ......
  • Mark Wallinger.
  • Mark Wallinger Tate Britain London January 15 to August 27 Brian Haw's demonstration against the UN sanctions against Iraq started in 2001, before the war, and grew into a roadside barricade of images, photos, banners and texts against that war ......
  • Bearing witness to tragedy.
  • Byline: Jeff Wright The Register-Guard The image shows Dr. Kamal Peiris trying to console a woman who's come to see him in the wake of the tsunami that washed over their coastal town of Moratuwa in the island country of ......
  • Portraying mass wartime rape in the documentary: Befreier und Befreite and Calling the Ghosts.
  • Within the last two decades mass rape in wartime has received international attention. The phenomenon is nothing new: since the beginning of history, rape has accompanied war. Historians have long portrayed it as a "natural" consequence of war, as the ......
  • Moral question: when does a foetus become a baby? What happens when the choice is between the life of a mother and the life of the unborn?
  • HERE is a brain-teaser. It happens around 55 million times a year. Sometimes it is a surgical operation, sometimes not. Sometimes it is legal, sometimes a crime; sometimes it is even referred to in a national constitution. It is viewed ......

Related Topics