Indians take British govt to court over 'racist' rules.

Byline: Rashmee Roshan Lall

LONDON: An estimated 30,000 Indians who left the mother country to work in Britain on the Highly Skilled Migrant Programme (HSMP) have begun the fraught task of taking the UK government to court for its allegedly racist new immigration policies.

The

UK, which allowed the Indians into the country under the four-year-old scheme on the understanding that they would work and probably settle here, is accused of changing the rules of disenfranchise coloured economic migrants arbitrarily and without warning.

Britain's new, strict HSMP rules, which officially came into force on December 5, will force Indians and other South Asians to leave the country because they no longer fit the highly-skilled migrant category. The new rules disenfranchise potential non-European migrants over 28 years old and earning UK salaries less than ? 35,000, say the affected Indians, British immigration lawyers and immigration campaigners.

Amit Kapadia of the newly-formed HSMP Forum that represents those affected by the changed rules told TOI on Tuesday "most Indians will no longer be eligible to stay on in Britain under the HSMP because the government is clearly trying to remove migrants like us. They unfairly say you will only qualify if you are younger and better paid even though the average Indian highly-skilled migrant can reasonably be expected to be over 28 years old".

He added, more in sorrow than in anger, "What is the difference between these people (the British authorities) and Idi Amin, who threw Indians out of Uganda one morning?"

Rhian Benyon of the Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants (JCWI), an independent voluntary organisation campaigning for justice and combating racism in immigration and asylum law, told TOI, "Britain's reform of its system of economic migration creates a definite, if indirect racial disadvantage for Indians and others from non-European Economic Area countries".

The JCWI is just days away from launching a massive political and public information campaign against the new rules.

The changed HSMP rules are the third in a series of stringent changes to immigration policy, making Indians unwelcome in the UK. In April, Britain suddenly announced migrants would need to have lived here five years instead of four to qualify for permanent residence. A few months later, it barred Indian and other non-European doctors from arriving to study and work here. By year-end, it changed HSMP rules. The first two changes to immigration rules are already mired in legal challenges.

The new rules may come under judicial review once the Indians' case is filed at the High Court in London. But when and if that happens, a verdict is not expected for several months. Chris Randall, chair of the Immigration Law Practitioner's Association (ILPA) representing 1,200 barristers, solicitors and advocates across Britain, told TOI, the case might be a challenging one.

At least 49,000 migrants are expected to be affected by the new rules, of which at least 60 per cent are Indian and the majority of the rest Pakistani and Bangladeshi.

In a sign of the seriousness of the situation for Indians, officials of the Indian High Commission have met those affected by the new rules. The High Commission is understood to be keen to lobby the British Home Office and Foreign Office for a fairer immigration policy that does not disenfranchise Indians and other Commonwealth nationals.

The new rules have already drawn fierce criticism from ILPA, which asked - and was peremptorily refused - a request to meet immigration minister Liam Byrne last month, warned that the new rules with the deeply unfair points system could prevent even high-profile entrepreneurs such as Steve Jobs, co-founder and chief executive of Apple Computer, from qualifying for the right to work here.

The new rules would stop talented individuals from entering the country while migrants already here "will not now qualify to extend their leave to remain (in a move that was) unfair and unreasonable".

But the minister insisted the government had no reason to consult widely with affected stakeholders. He said "We have made these changes in order to make sure that the people who succeed under the programme are those who will make the greatest contribution to the UK economy, to make the requirements clearer and more objective and to make sure that the programme is robust against abuse."

The JCWI said Britain's hardline new immigration policy with respect to non-EEA nationals was part of a larger plan that factors in "an expanded European Union (of 27 countries) and the belief that Europe should now be the reservoir of all labour market requirements".

It added that Britain's new immigration rules for "all non-EEA nationals, including those from the developing world, wishing to immigrate for work and study, is in danger of replicating the racial injustice which is a feature of our socially unjust planet with its huge gaps in international wealth and development."

It said Britain was being hypocritical in insisting it would make all its laws non-discriminatory but leaving immigration law outside the purview of this.

Related Articles

  • Good or bad: Britain tears itself to pieces on immigration issue.
  • Byline: Rashmee Roshan Lall LONDON: A furious debate on the merits - or otherwise - of immigration has erupted in Britain with an influential anti-immigration pressure group controversially computing the economic benefit of migration at just four pence a week ......
  • UK penalises more Indians than other docs.
  • Byline: RASHMEE ROSHAN LALL LONDON: Nearly 60 per cent of all doctors disciplined by the General Medical Council (GMC) belong to Britain's ethnic minority communities and one in three doctors erased from the GMC register are from India, The Times ......
  • Migrant Indians to move court.
  • Byline: RASHMEE ROSHAN LALL LONDON: Several hundred Indians will formally apply to the high court in London on Monday, February 5, for permission to force the British government to submit to a judicial review of worker immigration laws they allege ......
  • Indian sub-con makes for population explosion in UK.
  • Byline: Rashmee Roshan Lall LONDON: South Asians or citizens of 'new Commonwealth' nations such as India, Pakistan and Bangladesh were the largest single group of immigrants to the UK last year, government number-crunchers have computed. An estimated 121,000 arrivals from ......
  • Disenfranchised Indians take to streets in London.
  • Byline: Rashmee Roshan Lall LONDON: Hundreds of Indians have launched a formal street protest campaign against the British government's allegedly broken promises to an estimated 30,000 embattled Indians who left the mother country to work here under the Highly-Skilled Migrants ......
  • UK Indians get Tories' support.
  • NEW DELHI: The younger generation of UK's Conservative Party leaders, led by shadow prime minister David Cameron, are working on a new immigration policy that will highlight the economic benefits to the UK from highly-skilled immigrants of Indian origin. "People ......
  • MPs join Indians' HSMP battle.
  • Byline: Rashmee Roshan Lall LONDON: Leading British MPs and peers have weighed into the battle being waged by an estimated 30,000 embattled Indians who claim the British government is victimising them by changing the rules of the Highly-Skilled Migrants Programme ......
  • Indians slam UK minister's tardiness.
  • Byline: Rashmee Roshan Lall LONDON: Indians campaigning against the British government's allegedly "unfair and retrospective" application of tough new immigration rules on the Highly Skilled Migrants Programme (HSMP) have expressed concern it is appearing to break promises all over again....
  • UK shuts door on unskilled Punjabi sweeper.
  • Byline: RASHMEE ROSHAN LALL LONDON: Goodbye Heathrow's Punjabi sweeper, as Britain has finally banned unskilled non-European Union (EU) workers from coming to work for the "foreseeable future". The ban, suggested sotto voce when the British government first unveiled a controversial ......
  • Lobbying for inclusion; rights politics and the making of immigration policy.
  • 0804751757 Lobbying for inclusion; rights politics and the making of immigration policy. Wong, Carolyn. Stanford U. Press 2006 225 pages $50.00 Hardcover JV6483 In looking at how immigration policies are made......
  • HSMP issue: India to talk to British govt.
  • Byline: RASHMEE ROSHAN LALL LONDON: Indian diplomats here have finally agreed actively and officially to plead the cause of an estimated 30,000 Indians who left the mother country to work in Britain on the Highly Skilled Migrant Programme (HSMP), six ......
  • Many UK Indians face deportation.
  • Byline: RASHMEE ROSHAN LALL LONDON: Britain has issued deportation orders to Indian IIM alumni and engineers working here on visas obtained under the Highly-Skilled Migrants Programme (HSMP). The Indians, who hold doctorates and post-graduate degrees from prestigious institutions such as ......
  • UK denies 'unfairness' to HSMP.
  • Byline: RASHMEE ROSHAN LALL LONDON: The British government has firmly denied claims by a key parliamentary committee that as many as 49,000 highly-skilled workers, many of them Indian, face deportation under "unfair...retrospective" changes to immigration policy, even as leading opposition ......
  • At the Heart of the Empire: Indians and the Colonial Encounter in Late-Victorian Britain.
  • At the Heart of the Empire: Indians and the Colonial Encounter in Late-Victorian Britain, by Antoinette Burton. Berkeley, California, University of California Press, 1998. xv, 278 pp. $55.00 U.S. This innovative and thought-provoking study focuses on the little-explored subject of ......
  • Change deportation orders, rules: Vaz.
  • Byline: RASHMEE ROSHAN LALL LONDON: Britain has issued deportation orders to Indian IIM alumni and engineers working here on visas obtained under the Highly-Skilled Migrants Programme (HSMP). The Indians, who hold doctorates and post-graduate degrees from prestigious institutions such as ......

Related Topics