The military's mess: Johnston Atoll, the army's 'model' chemical disposal facility, is an environmental disaster.

By: Rampell, Ed
Publication: E
Date: Monday, January 1 1996

Just 700 miles to the southeast of the sybarites enjoying the sun on Hawaii's Waikiki Beach, the U.S. Army maintains a $240 million island facility with a grim purpose. The Johnston Atoll Chemical Agent Disposal System (JACADS) exists solely for the purpose of destroying obsolete - and frightening

- chemical weapons.

Remote Johnston Atoll, despite its location, is no Paradise Island. It's been a dumping ground for lethal weaponry - and atomic bomb testing - since the 1950s. Its current mandate is the burning of up to 6.6 percent of the total U.S. chemical weapons stockpile. (The cache includes some 400,000 weapons, notably mustard gas and 400 tons of nerve gas.) In January 1995, the Army asked for an extension and an additional $650 million to complete its mission; last May, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) gave the Army a year's grace period.

The Army sought the delay because of what it called "unexpected problems" that included:

* On March 14, 1994, a fire occurred in the explosive containment area of the experimental plant at Johnston, where the U.S. Army incinerates much of its chemical weapons arsenal. According to EPA spokesman Ray Fox, "Rockets are chopped, then dropped down chutes of deactivation furnaces. There was a misfortune - a spark went up through the chute and ignited a rocket. Although there was some damage which necessitated shutdown for a few days, there was no nerve agent release or injury";

* On March 23, 1994, there was an accidental release of live nerve agent GB from a JACADS smokestack. This 25-minute exposure was at least 10 times greater than the EPA's allowable levels. There were no injuries, but JACADS was shutdown for nearly four months;

* On Dec. 24, 1994, there was a fire at JACADS caused by "a coolant line that came apart, spraying coolant on the hot surface of the deactivation furnace. The fire lasted until the coolant burned out. There was soot, but no damage to equipment," according to EPA's Fox.

* JACADS, it seems, gets shut down as often as some rogue nuclear plants. Activist Craig Williams of the Chemical Weapons Working Group (CWWG) and the Kentucky Environmental Foundation (KEE) alleges, "There have been so many shutdowns. JACADS is down more than 50 percent of the time."

But Johnston Atoll's calamities started long before construction of JACADS began in 1985. The island is located outside the boundaries covered by the South Pacific Nuclear-Free Zone Treaty and is not subject to all U.S. environmental laws.

According to New Zealander Owen Wilkes, a longtime disarmament advocate, "On Johnston Atoll in 1962, the U.S. shot nuclear warheads out into space to study the effects of nuclear blasts on radio, radar and satellites. The first missile was partially successful. The next went off-course and plunged into deep water, from which its nuclear warhead was never recovered. The third blew up immediately overhead, and falling debris injured two workers on the atoll. The fourth exploded in space and caused a brilliant artificial aurora that was seen from Alaska to Antarctica. Many people thought it was the end of the world." The atmospheric test resulted in the release of plutonium at Johnston, which is a half mile wide by two miles long.

According to "Mr. D.," a defense industry source knowledgeable about JACADS, speaking on condition of anonymity, a nuke "went off the launch pad and cracked ... The missile did not go off, but it cracked the casing, releasing plutonium." The radioactive area, he said, is "still off-limits via a chain link fence." In what amounts to the world's first and largest plutonium mining project, the U.S. is spending $10 million to separate contaminated soil at the atomic atoll.

Plutonium is not the only lethal substance to leak into Johnston. In the 1970s, the U.S. shipped to the atoll millions of gallons of dioxin-contaminated Agent Orange, the birth defect-causing defoliant used in Vietnam. According to Mr. D., "The Agent Orange was stored in 55-gallon drums, which rusted, and the Agent Orange leaked into the soil." This still-contaminated area is also fenced off. According to Wilkes, the herbicide was finally burned in 1976 on the Vulcanus II incinerator ship, which he calls "notoriously inefficient." He adds, "Here, to an extreme degree, the U.S. military does anything that is too unpopular, too dangerous and too secret to do elsewhere in the Pacific."

The poisonous atoll had drawn the attention of Greenpeace Pacific coordinator Sebia Hawkins, who comments, "I have to believe there are inherent flaws with the JACADS design. Johnston is one of the most contaminated places on Earth."

But despite acknowledging the many spills and shutdowns, both the federal government and the defense industry firmly support the Johnston Atoll base. John Fairbanks of the Army's Public Affairs Office at Fort Shafter, Hawaii, asserts, "JACADS proves beyond a doubt you can safely, environmentally destroy chemical weapons. There's never been any violation of safety procedures." Pro-JACADS sources cite a noble cause: ridding the world of terrible weapons of mass destruction.

Alternative technologies could dispose of the chemical weapons more efficiently and cheaply even at the sites where they are stored, charges CWWG's Williams, who is also national spokesman for KEE. Why is a Kentuckian so concerned about distant Johnston Island? Four miles from Williams' home, in Lexington, Kentucky, the Army stockpiles 1.6 percent of the U.S. chemical arsenal. (The federal stockpile is scattered among eight states, and JACADS-like facilities are possible in all of them. Only one plant is actually under construction in the continental U.S., in Tooele, Utah, home of 42.3 percent of the stockpile. The facility is troubled and has been the subject of several critical stories.)

Since the states have - unlike Johnston - resident populations, community protests in the 1980s forced the U.S. government to postpone construction of any incinerators. Instead, the process was relocated to Johnston, which, Williams asserts, was supposed to be a "showcase to prove it can be done." With growing calls for an independent investigation of JACADS, the "showcase" is blowing up in its supporters' faces.

CONTACT: Greenpeace Pacific Campaign, 1436 U Street NW, Washington, DC 20009/(202)462-1177.

Related Articles

  • And you thought jaws was scary.
  • So here's the situation: You've just won the Second World War and you're left with too many explosives, mustard gas-filled bombs, and other chemical weapons to store. What do you do? Well you dump them in the ocean of course....
  • War Games.
  • War Games We were always training what to do in case of flooding or a fire below deck or NBC attack which wasn't threat of reruns but an enemy attack with nuclear biological or chemical weapons pretending that a cloud ......
  • States asked to be ready to fight bio-terror.
  • NEW DELHI: Concerned over the possibility of terrorists using biological and chemical weapons to create large-scale destruction, the Centre has asked states to gear up to face consequences like bird flu, plague and other diseases caused by biological agents. The ......
  • Racing through paradise.
  • Racing through Paradise by William F.Buckley Jr. (Random House, 344 pp., $25) THE SEA IS not our home; we imposeourselves there, buying survival with every trick we know. Not a scrap of available knowhow is irrelevant. Thus you can lash ......
  • Impact of advances in science and technology on the CWC.
  • The objective of a recently initiated IUPAC project is to prepare an assessment of the impact of developments in science and technology on the operation of the Chemical Weapons Convention (CWC) as a contribution to the Second Review Conference of ......
  • 60 ways to leave your WMDs.
  • Former U.N. weapons inspector Hans Blix, now chair of the Weapons of Mass Destruction Commission in Sweden, presented the commission's report to world leaders in June. The report, titled "Weapons of Terror," puts forth 60 concrete steps for ridding the ......
  • Combat not always part of a hero's past.
  • Byline: Mark Baker The Register-Guard MONROE - They are dying every day. Have been for years, at a rate of more than 1,000 a day, just like 400,000 of their brothers died in battle more than six decades ago. Only ......
  • OPCW Academic Forum.
  • 18-19 September 2007, The Hague, Netherlands The tenth anniversary of the entry into force of the Chemical Weapons Convention was 29 April 2007, a date on which many nations publicly renewed commitment to the multilateral treaty system and to the ......
  • Pinocchio syndrome.
  • Thousands of men and women who served in Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, and Iraq in the course of the Gulf War have reported falling ill. Their symptoms - among them, chronic fatigue, joint pain, memory loss, headaches, digestive problems, and insomnia ......
  • U.S. OUSTS BRAZILIAN DIPLOMAT JOSE BUSTANI.
  • By Matthew Flynn [The author writes for Business News Americas in Sao Paulo.] After two months of trying to convince Brazilian diplomat Jose Mauricio Bustani to resign as director-general of the UN Organization for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (OPCW), ......
  • Rolling back deadly folly.
  • Byline: The Register-Guard The Cold War gave rise to many enterprises that were insane, none more so than the chemical weapons program. The United States manufactured thousands of tons of nerve gas, blistering agents and other poisons, simply because the ......
  • Agent orange.
  • Dr. Dernnis Furlong, the coordinator for the Gagetown fact-finding project into the use of Agent Orange, advised at a public meeting that information is now being gained through three sources. One involves a review of documentation of military and civilian ......
  • Beating the War Drums at Fairfax: Fairfax papers have been presented as more balanced in their war coverage.
  • On 25 March 2003, just as the allied invasion of Iraq got underway, the Age carried a story reporting that advancing allied soldiers had discovered 'a vast chemical weapons factory' in central Iraq. The claims were quickly shown to be ......
  • Science, scientists, and society.
  • I am passionate about the civilizing effects of science. That does not make me insensible to the dangers of science, but they pale beside the dangers of pseudoscience. Think of the fascist and the communist movements, so much intertwined. One ......

Related Topics