TNS Media Intelligence's (TNSMI) third-quarter 2005 short-form DRTV numbers reflect a 10-percent gain of $65 million over the same period during 2004. This marks the third consecutive quarter that short-form billings have risen over the previous year's results. The total number of campaigns also
SOHO So High
Nine of the 17 TNSMI categories experienced increases in spending compared to 3Q 2004. In terms of dollars, the "Computers, software and home office" category had the highest gain, rebounding from its second-quarter demise of $11.8 million with a 40-percent surge of $36 million in 3Q. "Publishers and book clubs" shared the same percentage gain--a $10.1 million bump for the category.
Percentage-wise, "Multiple category ad" led the way with a 68.9-percent gain of $3.8 million, while the "Automotive and travel" category followed suit with a 62.9-percent gain of $16.6 million. Also notable, was the "Audio supplies and equipment" category's performance, gaining an extra $9.75 million for a 16.8-percent advance.
Among the eight categories that declined, the "Crafts, hobbies, sporting goods and toys" category witnessed the sharpest dollar drop with a $7 million slide (down 15.7 percent). Four other categories slid a moderate $3-4 million dollars, while the remaining three kept losses below $2 million.
Our Dog Spot
Similar to second-quarter results, four of the five outlets showed improvement against 3Q 2004 results. Spot TV was the only dog, with a $4.9 million decrease (9.6 percent). Hispanic Network TV made up for its second-quarter decline with a $12.4 million increase (13 percent). Cable TV led the group in terms of extra dollars spent with $21.7 million. Network TV's $19.8 million leap and syndication's additional $16 million posted percentage increases of 60.5 and 37 respectively.
Ups and Downs of Average Costs
The top 40 campaigns accounted for 69.5 percent ($490.9 million) of the total money spent on short-form DRTV during 3Q 2005, while the top 10 campaigns totaled $283.1 million (40.1 percent). The amount a campaign needed to spend to enter the exclusive top 40 rose by $419,000. The average cost of a campaign increased slightly--3.8 percent or $21,309. However, the average cost a campaign minus the top 40 declined by 8.3 percent--$16,493.
As always, the staff of Response thanks TNS Media Intelligence (TNSMI) for providing this valuable resource and allowing us to analyze and share the results with our subscribers.
Analysis by Shay Moftakhar, Special to Response
Fig. 1 Total Quarterly Short-Form Media Billings
3Q 2004 Short-Form $640,749,100
3Q 2005 Short-Form $705,825,100
Note: Table made from bar graph.
Fig. 2 Third-Quarter 2005 Short-Form DRTV Media Distribution
Network TV: $52,427,800 7.4%
Spot TV: $46,292,000 6.6%
Hispanic Network TV: $107,871,700 15.3%
Cable TV: $439,652,300 62.3%
Syndication: $59,581,300 8.4%
Total: $705,825,100
Note: Table made from pie chart.
Fig. 3 Third-Quarter 2005 Short-Form Categorical Distribution
Apparel: $4,561,000
Audio supplies and equipment: $67,816,000
Automotive and travel: $1,472,700
Business: $45,807,300
Collectibles and art: $185,300
Computers, software and home office: $126,060,600
Correspondence schools: $614,000
Crafts, hobbies, sporting goods and toys: $37,610,100
Drug and toiletry: $153,784,600
Food and beverage: $1,052,800
General: $66,526,800
Home and building: $7,517,500
Household, furniture and appliances: $77,060,900
Lawn and garden: $6,245,700
Multiple category ad: $9,430,000
Publishers and book clubs: $35,518,200
Video supplies and equipment: $64,561,600
Total: $705,825,100
Note: Table made from bar graph.
Fig. 4 Top 40 Brands for Third-Quarter 2005 Short-Form
Reported Time Period: July 1-Sept. 30, 2005
TOTAL
Dollars
BRAND CATEGORY (000)
1. HP Computer Products Computers, software and home $55,912.7
office
2. Petmed Express General $47,894.8
3. Ingles Sin Barreras Video supplies and equipment $44,739.9
Various Videos
4. Liberty Medical Supply Drug and toiletry $24,018.2
5. Dell Various Computers Computers, software and home $23,030.5
Products office
6. Bowflex Exercise Equipment Crafts, hobbies, sporting $21,585.6
goods and toys
7. Time-Life Various Audio supplies and equipment $20,605.1
Recordings
8. Dell Dimension Computer Computers, software and home $17,900.5
Products office
9. Craftmatic/Contour Ind. Household, furniture and $13,887.4
appliances
10. Colonial Penn Insurance Business $13,515.6
11. CRE-C Drug and toiletry $12,812.0
12. Razor & Tie Various Audio supplies and equipment $12,746.2
Recordings
13. Mobility Products Drug and toiletry $12,393.9
Unlimited
14. Scooter Store Drug and toiletry $12,260.1
15. Castalian Music Various Audio supplies and equipment $12,040.4
Recordings
16. Enzyte Drugs Drug and toiletry $11,715.0
17. Paquete Desintoxicador Drug and toiletry $10,708.3
18. Gerber Life Insurance Co. Business $8,347.8
19. Sharper Image Appliances Household, furniture and $8,011.2
appliances
20. Gateway Various Computer Computers, software and home $7,616.2
Products office
21. Relacore Drug and toiletry $7,475.1
22. New York Times Newspaper Publishers and book clubs $6,922.7
Subscriptions
23. Table-Mate Household, furniture and $5,527.5
appliances
24. TVATLAS.COM Various Audio supplies and equipment $5,465.7
Recordings
25. Life Alert Misc. General $5,368.8
26. Floam Toys Crafts, hobbies, sporting $5,216.4
goods and toys
27. Mundo De Ingles Multiple category ad $5,195.3
28. Hongosan Drugs Drug and toiletry $5,172.2
29. Everlife Flashlight Household, furniture and $5,151.3
appliances
30. Prudentchoice Insurance Business $5,127.8
31. Financing Alternatives Computers, software and home $5,077.5
Computer Products office
32. Hoveround Drug and toiletry $4,636.4
33. Girls Gone Wild Various Video supplies and equipment $4,340.8
Videos
34. Zoobooks Magazines Publishers and book clubs $4,327.3
Subscriptions
35. Tempur-Pedic Inc. Household, furniture and $4,278.4
appliances
36. SonyBMG Music Direct Audio supplies and equipment $4,193.9
37. HP Compaq NX Computer Computers, software and home $4,057.2
Products office
38. HP Photosmart Electronic Business $3,982.3
Products & Equip.
39. 1-800-CONTACTS Drug and toiletry $3,841.3
40. Thyrin-ATC Drug and toiletry $3,777.2
Total Top 40: $490,876.5
Fig. 5 Third-Quarter 2005 Short-Form Categorical Breakdown: Dollars
Spent by Media Type
Reported Time Period: July 1-Sept. 30, 2005
Total Network TV Spot TV
Category Dollars(000) Dollars(000) Dollars(000)
Drug and toiletry $153,784.6 $12,417.4 $12,892.6
Computers, software and home $126,060.6 $11,388.3 $9,330.7
office
Household, furniture and $77,060.9 $7,093.4 $4,498.0
appliances
Audio supplies and equipment $67,816.0 $10,960.6 $1,673.8
General $66,526.8 $810.3 $2,532.5
Video supplies and equipment $64,561.6 $1,863.8 $1,279.0
Business $45,807.3 $5,637.8 $4,218.3
Crafts, hobbies, sporting $37,610.1 $1,541.0 $676.7
goods and toys
Publishers and book clubs $35,518.2 $173.2 $6,999.3
Multiple category ad $9,430.0 $102.7 $129.4
Home and building $7,517.5 $300.1 $1,373.9
Lawn and garden $6,245.7 $4.9 $320.1
Apparel $4,561.0 $13.9 $141.6
Automotive and travel $1,472.7 $99.4 $22.6
Food and beverage $1,052.8 $21.0 $95.2
Correspondence schools $614.0 0 $107.6
Collectibles and art $185.3 0 $0.7
GRAND TOTAL $705,825.1 $52,427.8 $46,292.0
Hispanic
Network TV Cable TV Syndication
Category Dollars(000) Dollars(000) Dollars(000)
Drug and toiletry $32,868.3 $64,893.3 $30,713.0
Computers, software and home $343.4 $92,512.9 $12,485.3
office
Household, furniture and $3,403.1 $55,205.6 $6,860.8
appliances
Audio supplies and equipment $4,731.4 $48,403.9 $2,046.3
General 0 $61,120.8 $2,063.2
Video supplies and equipment $47,057.8 $14,237.1 $123.9
Business $5.9 $33,980.1 $1,965.2
Crafts, hobbies, sporting 0 $33,102.8 $2,289.6
goods and toys
Publishers and book clubs $9,346.0 $18,900.5 $99.2
Multiple category ad $6,103.3 $2,964.2 $130.4
Home and building 0 $5,549.1 $294.4
Lawn and garden 0 $5,567.1 $353.6
Apparel $4,012.5 $354.6 $38.4
Automotive and travel 0 $1350.7 0
Food and beverage 0 $936.6 0
Correspondence schools 0 $388.4 $118.0
Collectibles and art 0 $184.6 0
GRAND TOTAL $107,871.7 $439,652.3 $59,581.3
Fig. 6 Total Short-Form DRTV Campaigns
3Q 2004 Short-Form 1,144
3Q 2005 Short-Form 1,214
Note: Table made from bar graph.
Fig. 7 Average Money Spent on a Campaign Based on Total
3Q 2004 Short-Form $553,835.91
3Q 2005 Short-Form $560,095.37
Average Money Spent on a Campaign Minus Top 40: $183,090.80
Note: Table made from bar graph.